← All sermons
Monday, June 8, 2026 · 35 min

When You Let Down the People You Love Most

Noah Herrin · John 21 (primary) · Gospel of John series

Noah Herrin preaches from John 21 about how followers of Jesus should respond to failure. Using Peter's return to fishing as the backdrop, he argues that the common responses - retreating, trying to earn back trust, or simply returning to what’s comfortable - are insufficient. Instead Jesus pursues us into our failure, confronts it honestly (the charcoal fire detail recalling Peter's denial), and calls us back to love and obedience. Herrin emphasizes that repentance means running to Jesus, not fixing yourself first, and that obedience sometimes leads to suffering because we follow Jesus for who he is, not for easier circumstances. He closes with a pastoral call for older believers to step into discipling roles in the church.

“I paid too much for you to keep running back to the corner of my kingdom.” · Noah Herrin

Take it with you

When you fail, run toward Jesus (honest repentance) rather than hiding or trying to self-fix; Jesus meets you in the mess and offers forgiveness. Practice one moment of obedience to Jesus rather than relying on your strategy or feelings. Older believers are encouraged to intentionally invest in younger Christians - discipleship is a practical outworking of restoration.

Highlights

Key Scriptures

John 21 (primary)Peter returns to fishing; Jesus meets them on the shore, feeds them breakfast, and asks Peter three times, 'Do you love me?' - restoring him and commissioning him to feed my sheep.
Romans 8:1"Therefore, there is now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus." (used to remind listeners they are forgiven in Christ.)
John 2:5 (wedding at Cana)"Do whatever he says to do" - Mary’s instruction which Herrin uses as a motto for obedience to Jesus.
Proverbs 24:16"The righteous fall seven times, but they get back up." (used to encourage perseverance and recovery from failure.)

Topics